Brenda Joyce Smith, a construction superintendent, tripped over a tile pallet at her workplace, alleging that the incident caused a torn meniscus in her left knee. Post the accident, Smith had arthroscopic surgery that revealed arthritis-related issues but no meniscus tear. Further evaluations by Dr. Joseph McGowin, chosen by Smith, indicated her pain was primarily from preexisting arthritis, not a tear. However, a 2015 incident at Smith's home led to another MRI suggesting a potential medial meniscal tear. Dr. McGowin believed this tear was due to the recent event and not the 2013 workplace accident. Consequently, the Baldwin Circuit Court ruled that Smith's employer, Brett/Robinson Construction Company, Inc., shouldn't be liable for her additional treatment costs, attributing her issues to arthritis. Smith appealed, citing that even if arthritis was the root cause, the accident might have accelerated it. The Court of Civil Appeals, reviewing the substantial evidence standard, found that while there was some evidence suggesting a torn meniscus, it wasn't significant enough to challenge the primary diagnosis of arthritis. The appellate court thus upheld the trial court's decision, ruling that the employer wasn't responsible for Smith's additional treatment costs.
Court Denies Workers' Compensation Claim Over Injuries from Personal Dispute Over Work Equipment
City of Birmingham Appeals Workers' Compensation Decision after Employee's Fatal Shooting at Work.
Appeals Court Dismisses Workers' Compensation Claim After Employee's Death
Court Affirms Wrongful Death Was Work-Related
Court Dismisses Employer's Petition Seeking to Avoid Providing Panel of Physicians for Work-Related Injury
Tidra Corporation Wins Appeal Over Inappropriate Mental Examination Order and Disputed Medical Treatment
Sheriff Appeals Court's Expansion of Medical Expense Liability Beyond Initial Agreement
Alabama Court Ruling on Injuries Sustained En Route to Treatment of Workplace Injuries
The Court of Civil Appeals rejected the defendant’s claim that the plaintiff’s back injury was not related to a previous work accident.
Appellate Court reversed Disability Decision: Pre-Existing Condition
Court Affirms Permanent Total Disability for Back Injury Despite Pre-Existing Injuries
Snake-Bite Injuries Not Compensable
PTSD Claim Non-Compensable: Mental Disorders not caused by Physical Injury Fall Outside the Workers' Compensation Act
Court Partially Upholds Employee's Compensation Claim for Injuries Sustained from Lifting Garbage Can
Court Denies Worker's Compensation Claim, Ruling Work Did Not Cause Spinal Condition.
Court Reverses Summary Judgment Against Employee Seeking Workers' Compensation for Scabies Contraction and Resulting Psychological Injury
Court Affirms Workers' Compensation Award for Injured Worker's Work-Related Fall Despite Conflicting Testimonies
Lowe's Appeals Court Decision on Worker's Back Injury Claim
Reed Contracting Services, Inc. Challenges Court's Decision Mandating Knee-Replacement Surgeries for Employee Due to Work-Related Accident
McCall vs. Good Hope: Court Supports Medical Necessity of Treatment, Contests Attorney Fees
Court Affirms Permanent Total Disability for Back Injury Despite Pre-Existing Injuries
Permanent Partial Benefits Affirmed in Back Injury Case
Plaintiff Awarded Benefits by Appellate Court
PTSD Claim Non-Compensable: Mental Disorders not caused by Physical Injury Fall Outside the Workers' Compensation Act
Loss of Sight Ruled Compensable
Reed Contracting Services, Inc. Challenges Court's Decision Mandating Knee-Replacement Surgeries for Employee Due to Work-Related Accident
Fairhope Health & Rehab Challenges Compensation for Employee's Knee Replacement Due to Preexisting Condition
Court Challenges Evidence Linking Knee Injury to Worsening of Pre-existing Back Condition
Employee Awarded Permanent Total Disability Benefits
Procedural Dispute over Knee Injury and Permanent Partial Disability
Knee Injury Claim Denied: Not Work-Related and Didn't Cause a Disability
Plaintiff Waived Rights to Future Medical Treatment
Knee Injury Permanent Disability Reversed
Prior Employer Ordered to Continue Medical Benefits After Alleged Aggravation of Knee Injury