Patrick sued Mako Lawn Care, Inc., seeking compensation for injuries incurred during a work altercation under the Alabama Workers' Compensation Act. The dispute originated from the unauthorized use of his lawn mower, eventually leading to a physical confrontation with Landon McAnally. Patrick was found to have initiated the conflict, which culminated in Landon hitting him.
The Alabama law suggests that anyone actively participating in or starting such disputes can't claim compensation for resulting injuries. The trial court sided with the employer, stating Patrick's injuries were not related to his job. On appeal, the higher court assessed the situation in light of Sections 25-5-51 and 25-5-77 of the Ala. Code 1975, which grants compensation for injuries sustained during employment. However, referencing a previous case, Martin v. Sloss-Sheffield Steel & Iron Co., the court noted that injuries from disputes driven by personal motives—even if originating from a work-related issue—aren't compensable. Consequently, Patrick's claim was rejected, maintaining the original verdict.
City of Birmingham Appeals Workers' Compensation Decision after Employee's Fatal Shooting at Work.
Appeals Court Dismisses Workers' Compensation Claim After Employee's Death
Court Affirms Wrongful Death Was Work-Related
Court Dismisses Employer's Petition Seeking to Avoid Providing Panel of Physicians for Work-Related Injury
Court Upholds Decision Denying Worker's Compensation for Knee Surgery Linked to Arthritis, Not Workplace Accident.
Tidra Corporation Wins Appeal Over Inappropriate Mental Examination Order and Disputed Medical Treatment
Sheriff Appeals Court's Expansion of Medical Expense Liability Beyond Initial Agreement
Alabama Court Ruling on Injuries Sustained En Route to Treatment of Workplace Injuries
The Court of Civil Appeals rejected the defendant’s claim that the plaintiff’s back injury was not related to a previous work accident.
Appellate Court reversed Disability Decision: Pre-Existing Condition
Court Affirms Permanent Total Disability for Back Injury Despite Pre-Existing Injuries
Snake-Bite Injuries Not Compensable
PTSD Claim Non-Compensable: Mental Disorders not caused by Physical Injury Fall Outside the Workers' Compensation Act